Thrift Stores in Islip, NY
2 thrift stores in and around Islip, New York — call ahead to check donation drop-off hours and weekly sale days.
Rescued Treasures High End Thrift and Consignment
585 Montauk Hwy, Islip, NY 11769-1836
Best days: new donations usually hit the floor Monday–Tuesday after weekend drop-offs; senior and student discount days vary by store — call to ask.