Of the 3 thrift stores listed in Bay Shore, 3 give a phone number, 1 publishes opening hours and 1 has a website. No national chains here — every thrift store on this page is independent. By what they offer: 1 accepts donations. The nearest bigger selection is Oswego with 4.
-
St Peter's By the Sea Thrift Shop
500 S Country Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Mon, Wed, Fri, Sat 10am-2pm
Sells clothing, shoes, toys
-
Sinai Reform Temple Thrift Shop
39 Brentwood Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706-8031
Before you go
Store details marked on the cards come from each store's own website, checked August 2026.
Nearby thrift stores
-
Savers
2.8 mi · 478a Union Blvd, Islip, NY 11795
-
ON Thrift Store
3.4 mi · 90 Wicks Rd, Brentwood, NY 11717-3532
-
Nazary Thrirt Shop
4.1 mi · 1177 Suffolk Ave, Islip, NY 11717-4534
-
Good Samaritan Thrift Shop
4.2 mi · 179 Deer Park Ave, Babylon, NY 11702-2830
-
Reloved Clothing Store
4.4 mi · 22 Fire Island Ave, Babylon, NY 11702
-
Island home goods & thirft
4.9 mi · 51 Carleton Ave, Central Islip, NY 11722-3018
-
The Salvation Army Thrift Store West Babylon, NY
5 mi · 227 Little East Neck Road, West Babylon, NY 11704
-
IDEALthrift
5.4 mi · None , West Babylon, NY 11704
By feature
New York: rank 49 · Our methodology
Nearby in New York
- Oswego4
- Brentwood1
- Islip4
- Central Islip1
- West Babylon3
- Babylon3
- Lindenhurst1
- New York142
- Brooklyn61