Thrift Stores in Hayward, WI

Of the 5 thrift stores listed in Hayward, 5 give a phone number, 1 publishes opening hours and 2 have a website. 1 is a branch of a national chain — Salvation Army (1); the remaining 4 are independent. By what they offer: 2 accept donations. The nearest bigger selection is Madison with 41.

1. Northwoods Humane Society Thrift Shop

   15861 W 3rd St, Hayward, WI 54843

   Office is Open - Monday - Saturday from 11:00 AM to 3:00 PM.

   Where proceeds go: provide a sheltered environment for unwanted animals

   Accepts donations
   Call Website Directions

   Spotted an error? Let us know

2. The Salvation Army Family Store & Donation Center

   15693 Davis Ave, Hayward, WI 54843-6480

   Accepts donations
   Call Website Directions

   Spotted an error? Let us know

3. Finders Keepers Thrift Shop

   15409 Co Hwy B, Hayward, WI 54843

   Call Directions

   Spotted an error? Let us know

4. Poppin' Tags Thrift Store

   State Highway 27, Hayward, WI 54843

   Call Directions

   Spotted an error? Let us know

5. New Reflections

   15495 Co Rd B, Hayward, WI 54843

   Call Directions

   Spotted an error? Let us know

Store details marked on the cards come from each store's own website, checked August 2026.

• Take donations2

Wisconsin: rank 20 · Our methodology

• Cable1
• Stone Lake1
• Gordon1
• Spooner1
• Birchwood1
• Iron River1
• Madison41
• Milwaukee32