Thrift Stores in Put-in-Bay, OH

The single thrift store listed in Put-in-Bay gives a phone number and has a website. The nearest bigger selection is Youngstown with 15.

1. Lake Erie Island Historical Society Resale Shop

   443 Catawba Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456-6536

   Sells antiques & collectibles

   Call Website Directions

   Spotted an error? Let us know

Store details marked on the cards come from each store's own website, checked August 2026.

1. Kelleys Island Parsonage Resale Shop

   6.8 mi · 224 Division St, Kelleys Island, OH 43438

   Accepts donations
   Call Website Directions

   Spotted an error? Let us know

2. Goodwill Port Clinton Retail Store

   9.2 mi · 205 SE Catawba Rd, Port Clinton, OH 43452-2666

   Accepts donationsOnline store
   Call Website Directions

   Spotted an error? Let us know

3. Goodwill Port Clinton

   9.3 mi · 205 S East Catawba Rd, Port Clinton, OH 43452-2666

   Call Website Directions

   Spotted an error? Let us know

4. Truth Resale Store

   10.3 mi · 745 S Lake St, Gypsum, OH 43433-9501

   Accepts donations
   Call Website Directions

   Spotted an error? Let us know

5. The Lighthouse Center Resale Shop

   10.5 mi · 974 S Lake St, Gypsum, OH 43433-9506

   Call Directions

   Spotted an error? Let us know

6. Portage Resale

   11.6 mi · 301 W 2nd St, Port Clinton, OH 43452

   Mon-Sat 9:30am-3pm

   Accepts donationsFurniturePickup service
   Call Website Directions

   Spotted an error? Let us know

7. Grace Thrift Shop - Sandusky

   14.6 mi · 301 E Market St, Sandusky, OH 44870-2812

   Sat 5:30pm, Sun-Thu 9am, Tue 5:30pm

   Call Website Directions

   Spotted an error? Let us know

8. Something Good & Beyond

   15.1 mi · 1607 W Monroe St, Sandusky, OH 44870

   Call Directions

   Spotted an error? Let us know

Ohio: rank 33 · Our methodology

• Youngstown15
• Kelleys Island1
• Port Clinton3
• Gypsum2
• Sandusky10
• Huron3
• Bellevue3
• Cincinnati71
• Columbus65