Of the 14 thrift stores listed in Lancaster, 12 give a phone number, 4 publish opening hours and 7 have a website. 4 are branches of national chains — Goodwill (2), ReStore (1), Salvation Army (1); the remaining 10 are independent. By what they offer: 4 accept donations, 1 sells online, 1 offers pickup for bulky items. The nearest bigger selection is Youngstown with 15.
-
The Salvation Army Thrift Store
123 E Hubert Ave, Lancaster, OH 43130-4645
Mon-Sat 9am-6pm
Sells clothing, furniture, appliances
Free pickup of donated furniture
Where proceeds go: rehabilitation facilities for individuals with substance abuse issues
-
Lancaster ReStore
707 Slocum St, Lancaster, OH 43130-2456
monday thru friday 9am - 5pm
Where proceeds go: helping low-income families realize their dreams of homeownership
-
Bargain Boutique
1724 E Main St, Lancaster, OH 43130
Sells clothing, housewares
Donations: anytime the shop is open · takes quality clothing for men, women and children, as well as small household items
-
Goodwill
505 W. Fair Street, Lancaster, OH 43130
-
St Vincent DePaul Thrift
424 E Locust St, Lancaster, OH 43130
-
All Saints and Co
554 W Fair Ave, Lancaster, OH 43130-2369
-
Furniture with a Heart - Lancaster
1217 N Memorial Dr, Lancaster, OH 43130-1626
-
Madison Avenue Thrift Shop & More
215 Madison Ave, Lancaster, OH 43130-3118
Before you go
-
Merry Mae Market
6520 Duncan Rd SW, Lancaster, OH 43130-9262
-
Lil Sprouts Children's Resale Store
929 Ety Rd, Lancaster, OH 43130
-
Good Neighbor Thrift Store
241 Cedar Hill Rd, Lancaster, OH 43130-3639
-
D&J Consignment
1375 Old Logan Rd, Lancaster, OH 43130-4853
Store details marked on the cards come from each store's own website, checked August 2026.
By feature
Ohio: rank 33 · Our methodology