All states›New York›Oyster Bay

Thrift Stores in Oyster Bay, NY

5 thrift stores in and around Oyster Bay, New York.

Oyster Bay has about 299,540 residents, which works out to 1.7 thrift stores per 100,000 people — New York as a whole has 6.3. Population: U.S. Census Bureau, 2024 estimate.

5thrift stores
1.7per 100,000 residents
5with a phone
1website-checked

Of the 5 thrift stores listed in Oyster Bay, 5 give a phone number and 2 have a website. No national chains here — every thrift store on this page is independent. By what they offer: 1 sells online, 1 accepts donations. The nearest bigger selection is Huntington with 6.

Oyster Bay 5 thrift stores

  1. Next To New Boutique

    59 W Main St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771

    Sells clothing, jewelry

    Accepts donationsOnline store
    Call Website Directions

    Spotted an error? Let us know

  2. 1st Source Consignment

    23 Newtown Rd, Oyster Bay, NY 11803

    Call Website Directions

    Spotted an error? Let us know

  3. Hope Thrift Shop

    98 Audrey Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771-1546

    Call Directions

    Spotted an error? Let us know

  4. Attic Door Furniture

    33 E Main St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771-2415

    Call Directions

    Spotted an error? Let us know

  1. Hope For Long Island Thrift Store

    98A Audrey Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771-1546

    Call Directions

    Spotted an error? Let us know

Before you go

Store details marked on the cards come from each store's own website, checked August 2026.

By feature

New York: rank 49 · Our methodology

Nearby in New York