The single thrift store listed in New Castle gives a phone number, publishes opening hours and has a website. By what they offer: 1 has a furniture section, 1 accepts donations. The nearest bigger selection is Oswego with 4.
-
Fantastic Finds
400 King St, New Castle, NY 10514-3500
Mon-Sat 10am-4pm
Sells clothing, accessories, jewelry, furniture, housewares, appliances, art & decor
Donations: Donations are currently by appointment only. · takes Men’s and women’s clothing, accessories, small or accent furniture, small appliances, home décor · not accepted: Bathing suits, bedding, books, children’s clothing, computers, DVDs/CDs, large furniture, toys
Where proceeds go: Support Connection’s free, year-round breast, ovarian, and gynecological cancer support services.
Before you go
Store details marked on the cards come from each store's own website, checked August 2026.
Nearby thrift stores
-
Opportunity Shop
0.3 mi · 61 N Greeley Ave Ste 1, Chappaqua, NY 10514-3472
-
St John's Episcopal Church
2 mi · 8 Sunnyside Ave, Pleasantville, NY 10570-3125
-
Pamela's - Women & Children’s Clothing, Shoes, Jewelry & More
2.8 mi · 796 Commerce St, Thornwood, NY 10594
-
TWIGS Thriftree of NWH Inc.
2.9 mi · 449 Lexington Ave, Mt Kisco, NY 10549
-
Luxe luxury labels
3.6 mi · 41 Maple Ave, Armonk, NY 10504-1825
-
Treasure Trunk Thrift Shop
3.6 mi · 200 E Main St, Mt Kisco, NY 10549-2949
-
Thryve Thrift Studio
3.9 mi · 19 E Main St, Mt Kisco, NY 10549-2218
By feature
New York: rank 49 · Our methodology