Thrift Stores in Leicester, NY

The single thrift store listed in Leicester gives a phone number and has a website. By what they offer: 1 has a furniture section, 1 accepts donations. The nearest bigger selection is Oswego with 4.

1. 2nd Time Around Consignment

   123 Main St, Leicester, NY 14481-9652

   Sells clothing, furniture, antiques & collectibles, art & decor

   Donations: takes items you no longer need

   Accepts donationsFurniture
   Call Website Directions

   Spotted an error? Let us know

Store details marked on the cards come from each store's own website, checked August 2026.

1. Berto's Retro Rehome

   3.4 mi · 31 Main St, Mt Morris, NY 14510

   Call Directions

   Spotted an error? Let us know

2. Ultimate Bargains Thrift Shoppe

   3.5 mi · 80 Main St, Mt Morris, NY 14510-1251

   Call Directions

   Spotted an error? Let us know

3. Not Dot Shop

   4.5 mi · 127 Main St, Geneseo, NY 14454-1260

   Call Website Directions

   Spotted an error? Let us know

4. Florence's Perpetual Estate Sale

   4.5 mi · 133 Main St, Geneseo, NY 14454-1277

   Wed 10-5, Thu 10-5, Fri 10-5, Sat 10-4, Sun 11:30-3:30

   Accepts donations
   Call Website Directions

   Spotted an error? Let us know

5. Goodwill

   5.5 mi · 4119 Lakeville Rd, Geneseo, NY 14454-1119

   Accepts donationsOnline store
   Call Website Directions

   Spotted an error? Let us know

6. The Community Clothes Closet and Thrift Store

   6.4 mi · 6 N Main St, Perry, NY 14530

   Accepts donations
   Call Website Directions

   Spotted an error? Let us know

7. Alley Cat Boutique

   10.3 mi · 5604 Big Tree Rd, Lakeville, NY 14480-9772

   Call Website Directions

   Spotted an error? Let us know

8. UMCL Thrift Shoppe

   12.2 mi · 6 Spring St, Livonia, NY 14487-9704

   Call Directions

   Spotted an error? Let us know

• Furniture section1
• Take donations1

New York: rank 49 · Our methodology

• Oswego4
• Mt Morris2
• Geneseo3
• Perry1
• Lakeville1
• Livonia1
• Avon1
• New York142
• Brooklyn61