Of the 2 thrift stores listed in Middletown, 2 give a phone number, 1 publishes opening hours and 2 have a website. 1 is a branch of a national chain — Plato's Closet (1); the remaining one is independent. By what they offer: 1 accepts donations. The nearest bigger selection is Hazlet with 3.
-
Calico Cat Thrift Shoppe
92 Kings Hwy, Middletown, NJ 07748-2025
Sells clothing
Where proceeds go: low-income families and individuals in the community
-
Plato's Closet
1421 State Route 35, Middletown, NJ 07748-2030
mon–sat: 10am–9pm
Sells clothing, shoes
Before you go
Store details marked on the cards come from each store's own website, checked August 2026.
Nearby thrift stores
-
Bo's Attic
2.1 mi · 455 State Route 36, Port Monmouth, NJ 07758-1328
Hours: Mon - Sat 9 AM til 6 PM Sunday 12 - 5 PM
-
Goodwill Store & Donation Center
3.4 mi · 3035-B State Highway 35 N, Hazlet, NJ 07730
-
Poole Ave Liqours Karaoke
4 mi · Poole Ave, Hazlet, NJ 07730
-
St. Agnes Thrift Shop
4.1 mi · Ave D & South Ave, Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716
-
Trendy Tots Children's Consignment
4.1 mi · 1348 State Route 36, Hazlet, NJ 07730-1716
m - f: 10 am - 5:30 pm
-
Pearl Street Consignment and Custom Clothes
4.3 mi · 117 Monmouth St, Red Bank, NJ 07701-1110
-
Nearly New Shop
4.3 mi · 70 Monmouth St Ste 1, Red Bank, NJ 07701-1665
-
Retro Flair
4.4 mi · 27 Monmouth St, Red Bank, NJ 07701-1650
By feature
New Jersey: rank 50 · Our methodology