All states › New York › Best of 2026

🏆 The 10 Best Thrift Stores in New York — 2026

We compared all 758 thrift stores in New York on the data that matters: services offered, posted hours, and how easy each one is to reach. No pay-to-play — this ranking comes straight from the listings data, updated July 2026.

#1 · 2nd Chance ConsignmentNiagara Falls

+17162831382 Website View listing

#2 · 2nd Time Around ConsignmentLeicester

+15853825064 Website View listing

#3 · 48 KidsCattaraugus

+17162165437 Website View listing

#4 · A Second Thought Resale ShopEast Rochester

+15853405730 Website View listing

#5 · A T Stewart ExchangeGarden City

+15167468900 Website View listing

#6 · AMVETS Thrift StoreDepew

(716) 681-8337 Website View listing

#7 · AMVETS Thrift StoreWest Seneca

(716) 675-7963 Website View listing

#8 · ARF Thrift & Treasure ShopSagaponack

+16315373682 Website View listing

#9 · Act II Consignment BoutiqueHuntington

+16317541800 Website View listing

#10 · Albany Adult Rehabilitation CenterAlbany

(800) 728-7825 Website View listing

Run one of these businesses? You earned this spot — email [email protected] for your free “Top Thrift Stores in New York” badge to put on your site, and we’ll make sure your listing stays accurate.
How we rank: every listing earns points for verified services (accepts donations, furniture, pickup service, online store), posted hours, and working contact details. The ranking is recalculated with every data update.